Continuing on from my
previous 9/11-themed blog post, here's a look at some of the more sinister examples of advertising which exploited the tragedy of the event and its global impact. It seems advertisers just can't seem to stay away from the iconic imagery of the twin towers of the World Trade Center (WTC) in lower Manhattan, New York City.
Here is a recent example of 9/11 themed advertising for
USA Discounters. USA Discounters is a
not-so-popular credit store that "has been serving all military and government employees since May 1991." The towering body copy is the Declaration of Independence.
The tagline reads "The things we stand for still stand".
What a tacky ten year anniversary.
On the anniversary of 9/11 in 2007, the
Khaleej Times,"the No. 1 English language daily paper published in Dubai, United Arab Emirates," employed a cheap visual trick in this full page anti-smoking ad. The headline message reads "5.4 million people die of smoking related causes every year. That's 2000 times a 9/11."
 |
ASH (Action for Smoking Health)
Ad Agency: DDB NZ |
Another cigarrette / tower visual theme was used by DDB NZ for
ASH (Action for Smoking Health). This New Zealand based ad is almost a direct rip-off of the Khaleej Times ad which came out a year earlier in Dubai.
Why not go a step further and have a sky blue colored lighter - with an airplane graphic on its side, coming in sideways lighting up the cigarette towers. Little pieces of ash could be added - floating off the top to represent the WTC victims who jumped to their death.
If you don't quit smoking, will that be a victory to the terrorists?
We get it. Smoking kills. But it is really necessary to present the message this way?
 |
"Titanic", Solidarités
Ad Agency: BBDP & FILS, Paris, France. |
French humanitarian organization,
Solidarités, exploits TWO tragedies for its global health hazard - "non-drinking water." The goofy diorama equation of a sinking Titanic plus the twin towers - complete with paper cut out passenger planes looming, multiplied by 2000 (couldn't they find another world-famous tragedy where 2000 people died?) equals a glass of dirty, lethal non-drinking water.
Ad agency, BBDP & FILS, also produced a TV / digital ad for the campaign - complete with an odd, floating, drifty music box type background music.
I'm no math genius, but something in that insensitive sum just doesn't add up!
Another 9/11 print ad from France - this one for Paris-based weekly,
Courrier International. With the tagline "Learn to anticipate", the geniuses at Saatchi & Saatchi France have miraculously solved the tragedy by concluding that the WTC architects could have saved lives by only building the twin towers to about 50 floors.
Sacré bleu! The hijacked planes completely miss their target, each other and the ad misses any semblance of common sense and dignity.
 |
El Pais, Spain
Ad Agency: Ogilvy and Mather, Colombia. |
It's all fun & games for Spain's largest national newspaper,
El Pais. The double page ad offers a challenge to Spanish readers to spot the mistakes in this 9/11 image. For instance - did you know that the initial tower was hit much further up, the second plane to hit the WTC was not a Hercules military transport plane and the Transamerica Pyramid is in San Francisco not New York?
Yes. There is something wrong with this picture. But it's not just the photoshopping.
Another 9/11 exploitation ad for another national newspaper, this one is Russian weekly,
The Moscow News. This is the most artistically crafted 9/11 depiction of the bunch. A digital papercraft recreation of the exploding WTC towers.
Not artistically offensive enough for you? There's also a
Hiroshima version of this ad.
And finally, what I consider to be the pièce de résistance of 9/11 exploitation advertising over the last decade. DDB Brazil decided to mock up this print ad (allegedly without the consent of their client - the World Wildlife Fund).
A broadcast version of the "Tsunami" ad was also produced.
The message in these ads, once again reduces the 9/11 tragedy to the number of deaths. After recreating the event digitally and then adding extra passenger jets, the ad claims:
"In 2005, the tsunami killed 280,000 people.
That's 100 times more deaths.
Our planet is brutally powerful.
Respect it.
Conserve it."
After presenting the campaign idea to the client, the
World Wildlife Fund or WWF, (where it was summarily rejected), the agency secretly ran the print version of the ad in a small Sao Paulo newspaper. This was so the campaign could then be entered into advertising awards shows such as the
One Show event in 2009.
Read the story of the full schemozzle of a SNAFU
here.
Ultimately, the group of creatives at DDB Brasil were so enamoured with their campaign, they lost sight of the fact they were comparing a man-made global terrorist act with an act of nature. Both were catastrophic yet incomparable. Going behind the back of the WWF so it could be award show eligible scaled the depths of poor taste to serve narrow-minded egos.
It is quite clear from all of these ads (notice how the majority are from agencies outside North America) that the use of 9/11 imagery without any sensibility or empathy has only shown to exploit the event. People might equate it to anti-American sentiment abroad, but ultimately it's poor judgement and decision making by the creative directors who signed it off.
